Margaret River Winery Tours: Guided vs Self-Drive

People ask me if they should book a tour or do it themselves. My answer is always the same: it depends on whether you want to learn about wine or whether you want to have a good day. Those aren't always the same thing.

I'm not a wine writer. I make furniture two minutes off Caves Road and watch visitors come and go from the cellar doors. After forty years of conversations on the bench in the workshop, I have a fairly settled view on this question, and the view doesn't favour either option universally.

Photo: Sue Winston, Unsplash License

A guided tour is built around getting six or eight people through four cellar doors and back to their accommodation by dinner. The day is choreographed. The wineries know the buses are coming, they have a tasting flight ready, and the staff are pleasant and efficient. Nobody is rude. Nobody is the standout host either, because they can't be — they have another van pulling in behind yours.

A self-drive is built around whatever you decide it's built around. That's the upside and the downside.

The trade-off is autonomy versus expertise. You can hire either, but you can't have both at the same time in the same day.

You lose the country between the cellar doors. The bus pulls out of one driveway and into the next, and the bits of Caves Road that I'd argue are the best of the wine region drive past your window in a blur. The Cape to Cape Track crosses Caves Road three times. The pull-offs where you can see down to the Indian Ocean are five minutes apart in places. A bus doesn't stop.

You lose the conversation. At a small cellar door on a quiet Tuesday, the person pouring will sit with you for half an hour if it's interesting. On a tour day with three other vans in the carpark, you get the standard pour and a paragraph.

You lose the timing. The bus leaves when the bus leaves. If you've fallen into a good conversation at the second stop, that's a shame, time to go. If you wanted to walk the labyrinth at Wills Domain after lunch, that's not on the schedule.

You lose the meal. Most guided tours include a platter lunch at one of the cellar doors with a generic menu. The proper restaurants are not where the buses stop, because the proper restaurants don't seat groups of eighteen at short notice. You're eating bread and cheese and meeting the wine where you stand.

Photo: undefined · via Wikimedia Commons

Nobody has to drive. That's not nothing. Tasting at four cellar doors and then driving home is illegal and stupid in roughly equal measure. A driver in your group means everyone tastes properly. A bus tour means everyone tastes properly.

You get explanation. A good tour guide knows the region, knows the families behind the labels, knows the difference between a Wilyabrup chardonnay and one from the southern end. If you don't know cabernet from shiraz when you sit down, you'll know quite a lot more by the end of the day. The cellar door staff give you the headline, the tour guide gives you the context between cellar doors.

You meet people. Some travellers want a tour day for the company. Six strangers in a van, sharing notes about each tasting, swapping bottles. That can be a fine day depending on the van.

You don't have to plan. For visitors with limited time and limited interest in the logistics, a tour is the easier purchase. Pick a date, book a seat, turn up.

Three cellar doors. One proper lunch. A driver hired for the day (more on this in a moment) or one person in the group elected to stay sober. A printed list of which wines you want to taste at each stop so you don't get the entry-level pour at every cellar door. Time to walk for fifteen minutes between two of the stops. Room in the boot for one bottle, not a case.

The pace is the thing. A guided tour does four cellar doors in five hours. A good self-drive does three in seven hours. You won't taste more wine — you'll taste less, with more attention.

For the actual route, a self-drive map and plan lays it out cellar door by cellar door.

This is the one most people don't know about, and it's often the right answer. A handful of small operators in Yallingup, Dunsborough, and Busselton will provide a driver and a vehicle for your group only. You set the schedule. They take you to whichever cellar doors you've booked. They wait. You leave when you're ready. They drop you home.

Costs roughly what two extra bottles of wine would cost across the day, if you're a group of four. Less per person than a seat on a bus tour. More privacy, more flexibility, no extra strangers.

The local operators worth asking about: Margaret River Exclusive Tours, Yallingup Wine Tours (small, but they'll go off-piste). The cellar door staff or your accommodation host will know the current names. Ask them.

This is what I'd do, if I'd come down from Perth for a weekend specifically for the wine.

1. 9.30am

   Coffee in Yallingup

   Yallingup General Store or one of the cafes in town. The day starts before the cellar doors are open. Don't try to taste at 10am cold.
2. 10.30am

   Wills Domain

   First tasting. The valley view is the right way to open the day, and Wills is small enough that you'll get proper attention.
3. 12.30pm

   Cullen Wines or Vasse Felix

   Lunch. Cullen if you want the smaller, more austere experience. Vasse Felix if you want the bigger restaurant. Both are excellent. Allow two hours, longer at Vasse if you order the degustation.
4. 3.30pm

   Aravina Estate or Clairault Streicker

   Last stop. A glass on the lawn. Skip the formal tasting. You've had enough proper wine for one day.
5. 5pm

   Back to where you're staying

   If you're not driving, this is when the driver picks you up. If you are driving, you stopped tasting at 1pm and you're fine.

Three cellar doors. One serious meal. A real conversation at the small one in the morning and a relaxed glass at the end. Notice it doesn't include four cellar doors, doesn't include the bigger names south of Margaret River town, doesn't include a degustation at Voyager. Those are different days.

Solo travellers. Couples whose preferences are very different and who'd rather not negotiate the schedule. Visitors with one day in the region, no rental car, and no interest in walking through the logistics. People who like meeting strangers over wine. Anyone whose group can't agree on a driver.

A guided tour also suits people who don't yet know what they like. The tour guide tells you about each pour. By the end of the day you'll know whether you're a chardonnay drinker or a riesling drinker, a cabernet drinker or a shiraz drinker. That's worth something on a first trip.

Groups of four. People with three days in the region rather than one. Travellers who've been to wine regions before and know how they like to spend a tasting afternoon. Anyone who wants to combine wine with walking, beaches, art, food, or the rest of what the region does. The self-drive day is the one that fits into a bigger trip.

If you want the bigger trip, an art lover's weekend in Yallingup and a foodie weekend itinerary both stitch the cellar doors into broader days.

I'll keep this short because there's a longer list of cellar doors with the best food. Briefly: Vasse Felix, Voyager, Cullen, Wills Domain, Clairault Streicker, Cape Mentelle, Leeuwin. Book the kitchen first, plan the tastings around it.

Photo: undefined · via Wikimedia Commons

If one person in the group is volunteering to be the designated driver, ask whether they actually want to. Some don't drink and they're happy to. Some drink and resent being the one who can't. That's a conversation you have on the way down, not on the morning of the wine day.

A hired driver removes that resentment from the day. It's worth the money on a wine trip, the same way decent boots are worth the money on a hiking trip. Sober one person and three drink. Hire a driver and four drink. The maths is straightforward.

Whichever way you do the day, the gallery is worth thirty minutes. Workshop on Blythe Rd, Yallingup Siding, eight minutes off Caves Rd at the Carbunup store turnoff. Free entry, viewing window onto the bench, jarrah and marri pieces in the gallery proper. Pamela curates the small art exhibitions. Tour buses don't come past, so it's quiet. Open most days to 5pm.

A tour day that includes a quick stop here in the middle of the afternoon is more memorable than a tour day that doesn't. A self-drive day with an hour at the gallery between two cellar doors is the right pace.

If you're here for two days or more, self-drive with a hired driver for the wine days. The matching question is where you sleep between cellar doors. If you're here for one day and you don't want to plan, book a guided tour. If you're somewhere in between, do one cellar door yourself on the first afternoon (Wills Domain, walk-in, no booking, a relaxed tasting) and a proper self-drive day with a hired driver the next.

Don't drink and drive. The roads are quiet down here but the consequences aren't.

Photo: undefined · via Wikimedia Commons